Curing cancer won’t redeem AI
Summary
Ruxandra Teslo treats data-center hostility as a nuclear-style mythology for the fear that machines will make people unnecessary.
Data-center objections are a mythology.
Water, power, and noise give a respectable body to the fear that the machines inside will render humans unnecessary, as nuclear plants once did.
Vague anxiety is hard to argue from, so the imagination gives it a body: water use, electricity demand and noise.
What if he also wishes to remain the author of his choices and circumstances?
Curing cancer cannot buy consent.
The pitch treats humans as creatures of material need; Teslo says a noble medical mission is not worth permanently deprecating most people's existence.
Most people become fluffy hamsters, well-fed and taken care of, but utterly insignificant.
Post-AGI abundance is the Grand Inquisitor's bargain.
Bread, certainty, and relief from self-government in exchange for authorship; Silicon Valley's religious means produce only material ends for everyone else.
Work is a ladder of agency, not a paycheck.
Most Americans report purpose in their jobs; careers train judgment, bounded status, and mobility, and labor scarcity has historically been leverage for political rights.
A PR problem is not an answer.
Musk-style job-loss forecasts have few moral frameworks attached, and meaning-making institutions cannot be rebuilt at the speed of the coming change.
And no, framing this as a “PR problem” does not count.
Read the original ↗Save to your Sponge
Summarized with Sponge. Quotes are the author’s own words.