← @bgSponge

Does Reddit have an astroturfing problem? What the data suggests

Summary

Peter Vijeh shows that 5% of brand-loyal accounts in knife subreddits write 11.3% of brand mentions in buying threads, exceeding the 7.9% expected by chance.

  1. Brand-loyal accounts exceed chance.

    In 1,000 random reassignments of author names, only 2 reached the 11.3% share held by the 49 most brand-heavy accounts.

    Only 2 of the 1,000 deals reached it.

  2. Concentration patterns match targeted campaigns.

    Three brands receive disproportionate mentions from loyal accounts, a pattern consistent with both paid campaigns and loud fan bases.

    That is the shape a few targeted campaigns would leave, and also the shape a few loud fan bases would leave.

  3. Account histories suggest organic users.

    The brand-loyal accounts have a median age of 4.5 years and spread mentions across 66 subreddits, unlike typical single-purpose paid accounts.

    The brand-loyal accounts are 4.5 years old at the median, the same as the comparison accounts.

  4. The method misses hidden actors.

    The study cannot detect paid comments from aged accounts, moderated content, or users with hidden Reddit histories.

    A paid comment that gets bought upvotes looks the same to this method

  5. Manual verification remains the best defense.

    Checking if an unfamiliar recommender has ever named a different brand is more effective than checking karma.

    click through and see whether it has ever named a different brand.

Read the original ↗Save to your Sponge

Summarized with Sponge. Quotes are the author’s own words.

More from @bg

All readings →