on cognition & embodiment—aka is ai going to take all our jobs:
Summary
floguo argues that cognition cannot be reduced to a brain in a box, using John Vervaeke’s 4Es and 4Ps frameworks to challenge the reductive nature of LLMs.
Cognition exceeds isolated brains.
Using Vervaeke's 4Es, cognition is defined as embodied, embedded, extended, and enactive, moving beyond passive data processing.
cognition cannot be simply reduced to a “brain in a box.”
LLMs represent reductive cognition.
The author suggests that embedding vectors compress entire worlds, potentially losing non-quantifiable data that is not vestigial.
what is lost in a world of compression?
Embodiment includes living.
True embodiment is not limited to seeing and doing, but encompasses feeling, noticing, perceiving, and living.
embodiment goes beyond simply seeing and doing—it is also feeling, noticing, perceiving, living.
Knowing requires four dimensions.
The 4Ps framework categorizes knowledge into propositional, procedural, perspectival, and participatory modes of grasping reality.
4Ps of knowing: 1) propositional 2) procedural 3) perspectival and 4) participatory
Highlights
what is lost in a world of compression? that data which we could not quantify its utility—perhaps it wasn’t so vestigial after all.
vervaeke developed the 4Es of cognition (if i’m not mistaken): cognition is 1) embodied 2) embedded 3) extended and 4) enactive
& 4Ps of knowing: 1) propositional 2) procedural 3) perspectival and 4) participatory
Read the original ↗Save to your Sponge
Summarized with Sponge. Quotes are the author’s own words.