← @bgSponge

Open Individualism and Antinatalism: If God could be killed, it’d be dead already

Summary

Andrés Gómez Emilsson treats personal-identity theories like conservation laws: Closed, Empty, and Open Individualism reframe whether birth harms anyone.

  1. Identity views act like conservation laws.

    Closed, Empty, and Open Individualism recast hard ethical questions the way energy conservation simplifies physics problems.

  2. Antinatalism usually smuggles Closed Individualism.

    Harm-by-coming-into-existence talk assumes narrative persons who might never have been born.

  3. Empty Individualism raises the stakes.

    Moments of experience can be beings whose entire existence is pain, with no later compensation to that subject.

    In my assessment, the mere possibility of Empty Individualism is a good reason to take antinatalism very seriously.

  4. Open Individualism plus Eternalism blocks cosmic off-switches.

    The subject is already born across tenseless block time; destruction, if any, is limited to our forward light-cone.

    it is not possible to help anyone by preventing their birth; the one subject of existence has already been born

  5. Prefer hedonic abolition over anti-natal policy.

    Antinatalist temperaments may self-select out of reproduction; commercially successful valence-recalibration is the surer path to close hell.

    Till then, us ethically-minded folks shall relentlessly work on building universe-sized fire-extinguishers to put out the fire of Hell.

Read the original ↗Save to your Sponge

Summarized with Sponge. Quotes are the author’s own words.

More from @bg

All readings →